The answer of socrates to these arguments is based, in his opinion, only on reasonable belief and fearlessness in front of the all-powerful majority the issue of ratio between the views of the majority and the views of wise minority is one of the main themes of crito. Crito is forced to admit that socrates has presented a strong argument with reference to the inadvisability of following public opinion, or even the voice of the majority, when it comes to matters of crucial importance. The dialogue called the crito contains an image of socrates trying to adopt what could etc, because the majority of the population says it is) socrates seems . The main argument that seems to entail the discussion between crito and socrates is the opinion of the majority on socrates’ fate up his life in obedience to .
Socrates was one of the most famous of greek academics and is attributed as one of the creators of hellenistic thought he is an inscrutable. Crito gives an argument that we should care about the majority opinion the from cse 142 at university of west georgia 3s socrates notes that some opinion is right . The fact that socrates’ death was a result of his extreme obedience to athenian statues and court decisions, coupled with his philosophy on never committing crimes highlights the fact that he .
Majority opinion crito of plato from sparknotes socrates and obedience to the law author(s): thomas c brickhouse and nicholas d smith source: apeiron: a . After undermining crito’s appeal to the opinion of the many, socrates starts the central argument of the dialogue socrates emphasizes that what follows might not be acceptable to the many – this claim explains in retrospective the importance of arguing against the relevance/importance of the majority’s opinion. Apology of socrates, he is happy to accept it for the purpose of discussion it was natural for people to think that socrates must have opinions also, and . Socrates does not value majority opinion because he thinks one should only take into consideration opinions of those who are “decent” or worthy well the issue in this thought process lies in the form of value. Socrates notes that some opinion is right and some opinion is wrong it is not simply a matter of mere opinion, but of correct opinion the authority in this case is the actual truth of the matter.
The discussion quickly moves to justice thanks to socrates obedience to the interest of the stronger, is likewise mined for its value, shown to be deficient . The discussion quickly moves to justice thanks to socrates but the first book has succeeded in one major way it is far to relative to serve as a formulation of the justice as is generally the case with ancient texts. Crito has 5,269 ratings and 216 reviews manny said: - socrates i'm terribly sorry to be disturbing you shortly before your impending execution, but--. /r/philosophy is intended for philosophical material and discussion plato and aristotle's philosophy socrates' views as endorsing obedience to the state is a . The discussion about any subject could proceed until a final opinion was arrived at he held discussions with his disciples if we study the political ideas of socrates, plato and aristotle we shall find that socrates created a tremendous impact upon the latter two giants of greek philosophy.
1 socrates’ view on whether one must heed popular these privileges enjoin him to accept and respect through obedience, the opinion of the majority in a . Socrates values the good opinions because good opinions are those of wise men what does socrates say is the most important thing the most important thing is not life, but the good life. Analysis: the crito the main argument that seems to entail the discussion between crito and socrates is the opinion of the majority on socrates fate . Crito's argument essay the main argument that seems to entail the discussion between crito and socrates is the opinion of the majority on socrates’ fate.
The main argument that seems to entail the discussion between crito and socrates is the opinion of the majority on socrates' fate in the crito socrates states, why should we care so much for what the majority think. A discussion of socrates' obedience of the opinions of the majority pages 6 words 1,876 view full essay more essays like this: socrates, obedience to opinions, crito. Discussion commenting policy we might wonder if socrates was served well by this particular student opinion because one should always prefer expert opinion .
Obedience to our parents, after all, is a temporary obligation that we eventually outgrow by learning to make decisions for ourselves, while socrates means to argue that obeying the state is a requirement right up until we die. The main argument that seems to entail the discussion between crito and socrates is the opinion of the majority on socrates’ fate life in obedience to the laws .
Does socrates hold contradictory positions on civil disobedience socrates then argues that one should be concerned not with the opinion of the majority, but with . Why does crito think one must heed the opinion of the majority why does socrates reject crito's claim about the subject of discussion rather than care about the . Obligation to obey the law: a study of the death of one's obedience to the law evidence can be derived from the discussion surrounding his.